MCU's Captain America Mantle: Anthony Mackie's Future
The persistent rumors of Chris Evans' return as Steve Rogers in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) stem from the cyclical nature of comic book deaths and rebirths. In comics, Steve Rogers has repeatedly died and been resurrected, with other characters temporarily taking up the Captain America mantle – Bucky Barnes and Sam Wilson, among others. This pattern fuels speculation about Evans' potential return.

However, the MCU operates differently. Unlike comics, the MCU generally maintains a greater sense of permanence in its storytelling. Deaths tend to be final, establishing higher stakes. Anthony Mackie, as Sam Wilson, is the current Captain America, and his portrayal emphasizes this permanence.
Mackie himself expresses hope for his continued role as Captain America, acknowledging that his tenure depends on the film's success. Producers and the director of Captain America: Brave New World confirm that Sam Wilson is the MCU's Captain America, emphasizing the character's distinct identity and leadership style, which will differ from Steve Rogers'.

The MCU's approach to character arcs contrasts with the cyclical nature of comics, aiming for lasting impact and significant change. While Steve Rogers' legacy remains significant, the studio intends to explore new avenues with Sam Wilson as the definitive Captain America, leading the Avengers into a new era. This departure from the comic book formula elevates the stakes and reinforces the weight of character decisions within the MCU narrative.